| 1916-1918 | Rev. Otis Tiffany Barnes |  The Bronxville Cabin, is named after him. He was the minister of the Dutch Reformed Church. |
| 1919 | Dudley Britton | |
| 1920 | William G. Hamilton | |
| 1921 | Ralph W. Gwinn | |
| 1922-1924 | Martin H. Ray | |
| 1925-1929 | Harrison Wright |  His son was the 2nd Eagle Scout in the Troop |
| 1930 | Charles J. Smith | |
| 1931-1936 | Markham Rollins | |
| 1936 | Roger Young | Became an Eagle Scout in 1927, |
| 1937 | J. Carroll Brown | |
| 1938 | Erwin Trapp | |
| 1939 | Charles Fisher | Became an Eagle Scout in 1927 |
| 1940 | George H. Knight | |
| 1941 | Walter Rutter | |
| 1942-1946 | Floyd S. Sanford |
|
| 1946 | Lincoln Warren | |
| 1948-1949 | Kenneth F. MacDonald | |
| 1950 | Vance McCraken | |
| 1950 | Louis Holderman | |
| 1951-1955 | William H. Grace | |
| 1956 | George Quinn | |
| 1956 | A. Paoli | |
| 1957 | Arthur Salinger Jr. | |
| 1957 | Thomas Lang | |
| 1958 | Jackson Smith | |
| 1959-1960 | Ambros Cram Jr. | |
| 1961-1962 | William A. Rabsey | |
| 1963 | Vernon Unger | |
| 1963-1964 | John K Northway | Also an Eagle Scout in the Troop |
| 1965 | John C. Halliday | |
| 1966-1968 | Parker Barrett | |
| 1969-1970 | Daniel L. Dyer | |
| 1971-1973 | Loren Kahle | |
| 1973-1978 | Mr. Penberthy | |
| 1978-1985 | A. Thomas Safford | |
| 1985-1989 | George Blyler | |
| 1989-1992 | Lee Schoenlank |  |
| 1993-1997 | Joe Lansing |  |
| 1997-2002 | Gaetano Marricco | |
| 2003-2005 | Peter Lenahan | |
| 2006-present | Richard Terp |  |
|
2007 |
FIVE SCOUTMASTERS left to right LEE SCHOENLANK JOESEPH LANSING GAETANO MARRICCO PETER LENAHAN RICHARD TERP
|
 |
